Choosing the right VPN affiliate program can make or break your earnings. In this Surfshark VPN vs TorGuard VPN comparison, we'll break down commission structures, approval processes, and earning potential so you can confidently pick the program that fits your audience.
Both programs target privacy-conscious consumers, but they differ significantly in payout structure, cookie windows, and approval requirements. Let's dig in.
Commission Comparison
The Numbers
| Program | Commission Rate | Cookie Window | Recurring |
|---|---|---|---|
| Surfshark VPN | 40% | 30 days | Yes |
| TorGuard VPN | 30% | 60 days | Yes |
Real-World Earnings Example
Assume you send 1,000 clicks/month with a 3% conversion rate (30 signups) and average customer lifetime value of $120:
Surfshark VPN:
- 30 conversions × $120 LTV × 40% = $1,440/month
- Over 12 months (with recurring): ~$8,500–$12,000 (accounting for churn)
TorGuard VPN:
- 30 conversions × $120 LTV × 30% = $1,080/month
- Over 12 months (with recurring): ~$6,500–$9,000
The gap widens with scale. At 5,000 clicks/month, Surfshark's 10% commission advantage translates to $3,600+/month difference annually.
Important caveat: Actual conversion rates vary. Surfshark typically converts higher (due to brand strength), which amplifies the earning difference further.
---
Cookie Window: 30 Days vs. 60 Days
What This Means
A cookie window is the timeframe during which a click is credited to you if the user converts.
- Surfshark (30 days): User has 30 days to sign up after clicking your link
- TorGuard (60 days): User has 60 days to sign up after clicking your link
Which Matters More?
TorGuard's 60-day window is a real advantage for:
- Research-heavy audiences (people who compare VPNs before buying)
- Content sites attracting casual browsers
- Newsletter subscribers who may not convert immediately
Surfshark's 30-day window is fine for:
- Direct-intent traffic (people already searching "buy VPN")
- High-quality traffic sources with immediate conversion intent
- Paid traffic where ROI matters more than time-to-conversion
In practice: Most VPN conversions happen within 7–14 days. The 30-day gap between Surfshark and TorGuard rarely impacts earnings for quality traffic, but it does provide a safety net for lower-intent audiences.
---
Network & Reliability
Both Surfshark VPN and TorGuard VPN operate in-house affiliate networks (not third-party platforms like Impact or CJ Affiliate).
Tracking Accuracy
Surfshark:
- Modern, JavaScript-based tracking
- Handles cookies reliably across most browsers
- Known for accurate real-time reporting
- Some iOS conversion loss (standard industry issue)
TorGuard:
- Similar tracking infrastructure
- Reliable conversion attribution
- Slightly longer processing times for payouts
- Less data transparency in dashboards
Winner: Surfshark — marginally better dashboard clarity and real-time reporting.
Payout Consistency
Surfshark:
- Pays on net-30 terms
- Direct ACH, wire, and PayPal options
- Consistent month-to-month (no unexpected clawbacks)
TorGuard:
- Pays on net-45 terms
- Fewer payment method options
- Generally reliable but slower
Winner: Surfshark — faster payment cycles mean better cash flow.
---
Approval Requirements
Surfshark VPN: Easy Approval
What you need:
- A website or content property with decent traffic (doesn't need to be massive)
- Content clearly related to privacy, security, VPNs, or tech
- No adult, gambling, or spam-heavy content
- Basic affiliate disclosure in your Terms of Service
Approval timeline: 24–72 hours (often faster)
What works:
- Tech blogs, privacy-focused sites
- YouTube channels with 1,000+ subs
- Newsletter with engaged audience
- Reddit communities (if you follow rules)
---
TorGuard VPN: Medium Approval
What you need:
- Slightly higher traffic bar than Surfshark
- Established brand presence (3–6 months old minimum)
- Active, verifiable audience
- Clear content alignment with privacy/security
Approval timeline: 3–7 days (requires manual review)
What works:
- Established tech sites with 10,000+ monthly visitors
- YouTube channels with 5,000+ subscribers
- Established newsletters with good engagement metrics
- Reddit accounts with history
Rejection reasons:
- Brand-new sites
- Thin content or low traffic
- Unclear audience or monetization intent
---
Features & Program Highlights
Surfshark VPN Affiliate Program
✅ Pros:
- Deep-linking support (direct to pricing page, feature comparisons)
- Extensive marketing assets (banners, text links, product comparison tables)
- Email swipe copy provided
- Real-time dashboard with granular data
- Competitive bonus structure for top performers
- No minimum traffic requirement
❌ Cons:
- 30-day cookie window (shorter than TorGuard)
- Occasional promotional restrictions
---
TorGuard VPN Affiliate Program
✅ Pros:
- 60-day cookie window (gives more time for conversions)
- Flexible promotion guidelines (fewer restrictions)
- Custom landing page support available
- Less saturated in some niches
❌ Cons:
- Lower commission rate (30% vs. 40%)
- Slower approvals
- Less comprehensive marketing materials
- Weaker brand recognition = lower conversion rates
---
Publisher Fit — Who Should Promote Which?
Promote Surfshark VPN When:
1. You have quality traffic — Your audience is actively researching VPNs or privacy solutions. Surfshark's higher conversion rate justifies the slightly shorter cookie window.
2. You want maximum earnings potential — If you're optimizing for revenue, Surfshark's 40% recurring commission compounds faster. Ideal for scaling publishers.
3. You're building long-term — Surfshark's brand strength means repeat recommendations perform well; audience trust translates to higher lifetime earnings.
---
Promote TorGuard VPN When:
1. You have research-heavy, casual browsers — Your audience compares options before buying. The 60-day window catches these slower converters that Surfshark misses.
2. Your site isn't approved by Surfshark yet — TorGuard's medium approval is more forgiving for newer properties. Use it as a stepping stone while building traffic for Surfshark.
3. You want less saturated competition — If your niche is oversaturated with Surfshark promotions, TorGuard can offer higher conversion rates due to less competition.
---
Related articles
- Surfshark VPN vs FastestVPN: affiliate program comparison → /compare/surfshark-vpn-vs-fastestvpn
- NordVPN vs Surfshark VPN: affiliate program comparison → /compare/nordvpn-vs-surfshark-vpn
- Surfshark VPN vs NordVPN Affiliate Program: affiliate program comparison → /compare/surfshark-vpn-vs-nordvpn-affiliate-program
FAQ
Q1: Can I promote both Surfshark VPN and TorGuard VPN?
A: Yes, absolutely. Many publishers run both simultaneously:
- Link to Surfshark for high-intent readers (direct recommendations)
- Link to TorGuard for comparison pages or lower-intent traffic
This diversifies income and reduces reliance on a single program. However, be transparent—don't mislead readers into thinking one is objectively "better" when you're simply earning more from it.
---
Q2: Which program has better conversion rates?
A: Surfshark wins by 20–40% due to:
- Stronger brand recognition
- Better marketing materials
- Higher user satisfaction scores
- Larger marketing budget (translates to brand awareness)
TorGuard's conversion rate depends on your traffic source and audience research habits. On comparison content, the gap narrows.
---
Q3: How long before I see earnings from these programs?
A:
- First conversion: 1–3 weeks (varies by user behavior)
- Meaningful earnings: 2–3 months (need enough traffic volume)
- Sustainable income: 6+ months (recurring commissions compound)
Both programs are long-tail earners. Don't expect immediate revenue; focus on consistent, high-quality traffic.
---
Final Takeaway
The Surfshark VPN vs TorGuard VPN decision comes down to traffic quality and earning optimization:
- Surfshark VPN is the obvious choice for publishers with decent traffic and approval standing. The 40% commission and brand strength make it a revenue powerhouse.
- TorGuard VPN works best for specific niches where conversion timelines are longer or where Surfshark approval isn't yet possible.
Start with whichever you can get approved for, then expand once you have both. Together, they create a robust VPN monetization strategy.