# ConvertKit Commerce vs Teachable: Which Affiliate Program Pays Better in 2024?
If you're choosing between ConvertKit Commerce vs Teachable for your affiliate marketing efforts, you're looking at two of the most popular creator economy platforms. Both power online courses, coaching, and digital products—but their affiliate structures differ significantly.
This guide breaks down commission rates, cookie windows, approval requirements, and ideal audience fit so you can pick the program that maximizes your earnings.
Commission Comparison
ConvertKit Commerce
- Recurring commission: 35% of monthly subscription fees
- Commission type: Monthly recurring (paid as long as the customer subscribes)
- Typical payout range: $25–$50 per customer subscription (depending on plan)
Teachable
- Recurring commission: 15% of monthly subscription fees
- Commission type: Monthly recurring (paid as long as the customer subscribes)
- Typical payout range: $7.50–$25 per customer subscription (depending on plan)
Real-world earning scenario (1,000 clicks/month)
Assuming a 5% conversion rate and average subscription price of $50/month:
| Program | Conv. Rate | New Customers | Avg. Revenue/Customer | Monthly Revenue |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ConvertKit Commerce (35%) | 5% | 50 | $17.50 (35% of $50) | $875 |
| Teachable (15%) | 5% | 50 | $7.50 (15% of $50) | $375 |
ConvertKit Commerce earns 2.3x more in this scenario—a difference of $500/month or $6,000/year.
Note: Both platforms pay recurring commissions monthly. If a customer subscribes for 12 months, you earn commission every month they remain active. This makes recurring programs significantly more valuable than one-time commissions.
---
Cookie Window: The Hidden Advantage
ConvertKit Commerce: 90 days
A user has 90 days from clicking your affiliate link to make a purchase. If they visit your site on day 1 and convert on day 60, you still earn the commission.
Teachable: 30 days
A user has 30 days from click to purchase. After day 30, the sale is attributed to direct traffic or another affiliate.
What this means for your earnings
A 90-day window is 3x longer than 30 days. In practice:
- Day 15 conversions: Both programs pay you
- Day 45 conversions: Only ConvertKit Commerce pays you
- Day 60 conversions: Only ConvertKit Commerce pays you
For content marketing (blog posts, guides, YouTube videos), ConvertKit Commerce's 90-day window captures users who research before buying. Teachable's 30-day window only works well for time-sensitive promotions or paid traffic campaigns.
Advantage: ConvertKit Commerce (by a wide margin).
---
Network & Reliability
ConvertKit Commerce
- Network: In-house affiliate program (managed directly by ConvertKit)
- Tracking: First-party cookies and UTM parameter tracking
- Payout consistency: Direct merchant payout; no third-party interference
- Reporting: Real-time dashboard on ConvertKit's platform
- Minimum payout: Typically $20–$50 threshold
Pros:
- Direct relationship with ConvertKit = faster support
- Accurate tracking (ConvertKit controls the entire funnel)
- No middleman delays
Cons:
- Smaller affiliate community
- Limited cross-promotion opportunities
Teachable
- Network: CJ Affiliate (Commission Junction)
- Tracking: CJ's proprietary tracking infrastructure
- Payout consistency: CJ handles all payouts and accounting
- Reporting: CJ Affiliate dashboard (additional login required)
- Minimum payout: $50 threshold (per CJ standards)
Pros:
- CJ is industry-standard; highly reliable
- Access to CJ's 1000+ other affiliate programs
- Established payment schedule (typically monthly)
- Fraud detection is robust
Cons:
- One extra layer between you and Teachable support
- Teachable support may not have visibility into CJ-tracked sales
- Potential for tracking delays during CJ system updates
Verdict: ConvertKit Commerce has a slight reliability edge due to direct management. Teachable via CJ is also reliable but adds complexity.
---
Approval Requirements
ConvertKit Commerce: Medium Approval (3–7 days)
What ConvertKit looks for: 1. Website quality: Needs to be professional, fully functional, and regularly updated 2. Relevant audience: Your content must relate to creators, productivity, email marketing, or digital product building 3. Traffic estimate: 500+ monthly visitors preferred (not always enforced) 4. Promotional methods: No paid search on branded keywords; organic content preferred 5. No competitor blogs: Won't approve if you heavily promote Mailchimp, ActiveCampaign, or other direct competitors
Application process:
- Visit ConvertKit's affiliate page
- Fill out form with site URL and traffic info
- Provide 2–3 blog post examples or top-performing content pieces
- ConvertKit reviews manually (3–7 days)
Approval rate: ~60–70% for sites with clear audience fit
---
Teachable: Easy Approval (1–2 days)
What Teachable looks for: 1. Active website/audience: Needs to exist and be accessible 2. No illegal content: Standard CJ Affiliate policy applies 3. Traffic not required: Even new publishers with small audiences can be approved 4. Minimal restrictions: Paid search on branded terms is allowed
Application process:
- Log into CJ Affiliate network (or create free account)
- Search for "Teachable" program
- Click "Apply"
- Approval is often automatic or within 24–48 hours
Approval rate: ~85–90% for first-time applicants
Verdict: Teachable is significantly easier to enter. ConvertKit requires more vetting but ensures higher-quality affiliates.
---
Features & Program Highlights
ConvertKit Commerce Unique Features
- 35% recurring commissions (industry-leading for SaaS)
- 90-day cookie window (long attribution period)
- Creator-focused audience: Easy to promote to entrepreneurs, writers, and online educators
- Marketing assets: ConvertKit provides email swipes, social templates, and case studies
- Dedicated affiliate manager: For top-performing publishers (top 50 affiliates get support)
Teachable Unique Features
- CJ Affiliate integration: Access to 1000+ other programs from one dashboard
- Flexible approval: Works well for new publishers or niche sites
- Teachable expertise: 500,000+ course creators on platform (bigger creator base)
- Promotion flexibility: Can use paid ads more aggressively
- Course creator tools: If you want to create your own course, Teachable offers revenue share opportunities
---
Publisher Fit: Who Should Promote Which?
Promote ConvertKit Commerce When:
1. You write about email marketing, creator business, or indie hacking
- Your audience already uses ConvertKit or is interested in newsletter monetization
- ConvertKit's features align naturally with your content
2. You have established organic traffic (500+/month)
- You want to maximize lifetime value (90-day window + 35% recurring)
- Long-term SEO content is your strength
3. You want higher earnings per customer
- Even at lower conversion rates (2–3%), the 35% commission builds recurring revenue quickly
Promote Teachable When:
1. You're building your audience from scratch
- Easy approval means you can start earning while growing traffic
- No minimum traffic threshold
2. You already run courses or online education content
- Your audience is explicitly looking for course platforms
- 15% commission still works at scale if you have high conversion rates
3. You use CJ Affiliate for other programs
- Consolidated reporting and payments
- Cross-promote Teachable alongside other CJ affiliate programs
---
FAQ
Q1: Can I promote both ConvertKit Commerce and Teachable?
Yes. There's no exclusivity clause with either program. You can mention both platforms in comparison content (e.g., "Best course platforms for beginners"). However, pick one as your primary recommendation based on your audience's specific needs. Be transparent about your affiliate relationship.
Q2: Which has better customer support for affiliates?
ConvertKit Commerce has more direct support because it's an in-house program. You can reach the affiliate team directly. Teachable through CJ Affiliate requires you to submit support tickets through CJ, which adds a layer of indirection. For technical issues, ConvertKit is faster (24–48 hours vs. 48–72 hours for CJ).
Q3: What's the best content format to promote these programs?
- Comparison posts ("ConvertKit vs. Teachable for online courses")
- Platform reviews with pros/cons and use-case guides
- Email sequences (ConvertKit Commerce works great in email content, given the product)
- YouTube tutorials showing platform features
- Reddit and community discussions where you can recommend based on user needs
Highest-converting format: Long-form comparison posts (1500–2000 words) targeting keywords like "best email marketing platform for creators" or "course platform comparison."
---
Disclosure
This article may contain affiliate links. If a reader clicks and purchases through a ConvertKit Commerce or Teachable link, AffiliPilot may earn a commission at no extra cost to the reader. We disclose this in the interest of transparency. Our analysis is based on publicly available program terms; commission rates and features are current as of 2024 but subject to change.
---
Final Takeaway
ConvertKit Commerce vs Teachable comes down to earnings potential vs. ease of entry.
- Choose ConvertKit Commerce if you have traffic, relevant content, and want to maximize commission earnings (35% recurring, 90-day window).
- Choose Teachable if you're building your audience, want instant approval, or are already using CJ Affiliate.
Both are legitimate programs with real earning potential. Start with whichever fits your current audience and authority level—then expand to both once you've built traction with one.
Related: ConvertKit Commerce vs Kajabi: affiliate program comparison
Related: Linktree vs VidIQ: affiliate program comparison
Related: Patreon vs Adobe Stock: affiliate program comparison